As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We research products independently, and commissions never change our picks.

Choosing the best Colombian coffee beans begins with the roast word, the form and the bag size in each title. This group holds four whole bean bags and one ground bag, the Amazon Fresh 32 Oz entry. The two Amazon Fresh 12 Ounce entries are one single bag and one Pack of 3 of the same coffee. Roasts read Medium Roast on four bags and Medium Dark Roast on Don Pablo. Every detail here comes from the Amazon product page and manufacturer information for each bag, and nothing was checked with real equipment in a home kitchen. Our editorial policy page explains how picks and scores are put together.

Best Colombian Coffee Beans: Quick Picks

Best Supremo Medium Dark Pick2LB Don Pablo Colombian Supremo, Medium Dark Roast, Whole Bean Coffee, Low Acidity, 2 Pound (2 lb) Bag

2LB Don Pablo Colombian Supremo, Medium Dark Roast, Whole Bean Coffee, Low Acidity, 2 Pound (2 lb) Bag

  • Medium Dark Roast in title
  • 32 Ounce Units
  • Low Acidity wording in title
Check Price on Amazon
Best Kosher Certified PickEight O'Clock Coffee 100% Colombian Peaks, Medium Roast, Whole Bean Coffee, 100% Arabica, Kosher Certified, 18 Ounce (Pack of 1)

Eight O’Clock Coffee 100% Colombian Peaks, Medium Roast, Whole Bean Coffee, 100% Arabica, Kosher Certified, 18 Ounce (Pack of 1)

  • Kosher Certified in title
  • 100% Arabica in title
  • 100% Colombian Peaks name
Check Price on Amazon
Best Ground Coffee PickAmazon Fresh, Colombia Ground Coffee, Medium Roast, 32 Oz

Amazon Fresh, Colombia Ground Coffee, Medium Roast, 32 Oz

  • Ground form in title
  • 32 Ounce Units
  • Medium Roast named
Check Price on Amazon

How We Score

We score each pick out of 10 on four criteria, using only what its Amazon product page states. A clearly stated, strong feature earns 8 to 10, a partial one 6 to 7, a feature the page does not mention 5, and one the page shows as absent or contrary 2 to 4. The overall score is the weighted total.
Criterion Weight What we look at
Roast Named 30% The roast level named in the title
Bag Size and Units 25% The bag size and the Units figure
Origin and Labels in Title 25% Origin and label wording in the title
Dimensions and Maker 20% Package dimensions and the manufacturer line

Compare the 5 Colombian Coffee Bags

Product Best For Type Key Spec Score
2LB Don Pablo Colombian Supremo, Medium Dark Roast, Whole Bean Coffee, Low Acidity, 2 Pound (2 lb) Bag Don Pablo Supremo Best Supremo Medium Dark Pick Whole Bean Coffee Medium Dark Roast; Whole Bean; Units 32 Ounce; 2 Pound (2 lb) Bag 8.6 View
Eight O'Clock Coffee 100% Colombian Peaks, Medium Roast, Whole Bean Coffee, 100% Arabica, Kosher Certified, 18 Ounce (Pack of 1) Eight O’Clock Colombian Peaks Best Kosher Certified Pick Whole Bean Coffee Medium Roast; Whole Bean; 100% Arabica; Units 18 Ounce 8.0 View
Amazon Fresh, Colombia Ground Coffee, Medium Roast, 32 Oz Amazon Fresh Ground 32 Oz Best Ground Coffee Pick Ground Coffee Medium Roast; Ground Coffee; Units 32 Ounce 7.6 View
Amazon Fresh Colombia Whole Bean Coffee, Medium Roast, 12 Ounce (Pack of 3) Amazon Fresh 12 Ounce 3 Pack Best 3 Pack Pick Whole Bean Coffee Medium Roast; Whole Bean; Pack of 3; Units 36 Ounce 7.3 View
Amazon Fresh Colombia Whole Bean Coffee, Medium Roast, 12 Ounce Amazon Fresh 12 Ounce Single Best Single 12 Ounce Pick Whole Bean Coffee Medium Roast; Whole Bean; Units 12 Ounce 6.6 View

1. 2LB Don Pablo Colombian Supremo, Medium Dark Roast, Whole Bean Coffee, Low Acidity, 2 Pound (2 lb) Bag

Best Supremo Medium Dark Pick 8.6/102LB Don Pablo Colombian Supremo, Medium Dark Roast, Whole Bean Coffee, Low Acidity, 2 Pound (2 lb) Bag
Pros
  • Colombian Supremo named in title
  • Whole bean form
  • 2 pound bag size
  • Medium Dark Roast named
Cons
  • No Kosher label in title
  • No Arabica share in title
  • Maker reads Cafe Don Pablo
Dimensions 4 x 5.5 x 11 inches
Weight 2 pounds
Manufacturer Cafe Don Pablo
Units 32 Ounce
Don Pablo leads this group with the Supremo name and a Medium Dark Roast, one step darker than the Medium Roast wording on the other four bags. The title calls it a 2 Pound (2 lb) Bag and the Units line reads 32 Ounce. Low Acidity appears in the title as wording. Cafe Don Pablo is the manufacturer, and the bag measures 4 x 5.5 x 11 inches. Shoppers who want whole bean coffee in the larger bag size get 32 Ounce Units here, against 18 Ounce and 12 Ounce bags elsewhere in the group. The title names Colombia through Colombian Supremo, and whole bean is stated in the title. Dimensions run 4 x 5.5 x 11 inches with a weight of 2 pounds. Score: roast named 9, bag size and units 9, origin and labels in title 8, dimensions and maker 8.

Who the Don Pablo Supremo fits best

Choose it if you want a Medium Dark Roast whole bean bag at 32 Ounce Units.

Who should skip the Don Pablo Supremo

Skip it if you want a Kosher Certified label, because this title names Low Acidity instead.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

2. Eight O’Clock Coffee 100% Colombian Peaks, Medium Roast, Whole Bean Coffee, 100% Arabica, Kosher Certified, 18 Ounce (Pack of 1)

Best Kosher Certified Pick 8.0/10Eight O'Clock Coffee 100% Colombian Peaks, Medium Roast, Whole Bean Coffee, 100% Arabica, Kosher Certified, 18 Ounce (Pack of 1)
Pros
  • Medium Roast named
  • Whole bean form
  • Kosher Certified label
  • Pack of 1 bag
Cons
  • Bag stops at 18 Ounce
  • No Supremo name in title
  • Pack count reads one bag
Dimensions 9.5 x 5 x 3.5 inches
Weight 1.17 pounds
Manufacturer Eight O Clock Coffee Company
Units 18 Ounce
Eight O’Clock puts two labels in its title that no other bag here carries together: 100% Arabica and Kosher Certified. The roast reads Medium Roast and the form is whole bean. Its full name reads 100% Colombian Peaks, and the bag is a Pack of 1 at 18 Ounce Units. The manufacturer is Eight O Clock Coffee Company, with dimensions of 9.5 x 5 x 3.5 inches. At 18 Ounce Units, this bag sits between the 12 Ounce Amazon Fresh bags and the 32 Ounce bags in the group. The weight reads 1.17 pounds. Colombian Peaks is the origin wording in the title, and Medium Roast matches three other bags here. Buyers comparing labels get Kosher Certified and 100% Arabica in one title. Score: roast named 8, bag size and units 6, origin and labels in title 10, dimensions and maker 8.

Who the Eight O’Clock Colombian Peaks fits best

Choose it if you want Kosher Certified and 100% Arabica wording in one whole bean title.

Who should skip the Eight O’Clock Colombian Peaks

Skip it if you want a 32 Ounce bag, because this one stops at 18 Ounce Units.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

3. Amazon Fresh, Colombia Ground Coffee, Medium Roast, 32 Oz

Best Ground Coffee Pick 7.6/10Amazon Fresh, Colombia Ground Coffee, Medium Roast, 32 Oz
Pros
  • Ground form in title
  • 32 Ounce bag size
  • Medium Roast named
  • Colombia named in title
Cons
  • Whole bean is not in title
  • No Arabica share in title
  • Maker reads Amazon Fulfillment Services
Dimensions 5.5 x 3.5 x 8.5 inches
Weight 2 pounds
Manufacturer Amazon Fulfillment Services
Units 32 Ounce
The Amazon Fresh Ground bag is the one ground coffee in this group; the other four bags are whole bean. Its title reads Colombia Ground Coffee with Medium Roast, and Units read 32 Ounce. The manufacturer line reads Amazon Fulfillment Services, a different maker line from the AFS Brands LLC on the two 12 Ounce bags. Dimensions read 5.5 x 3.5 x 8.5 inches and weight reads 2 pounds. Buyers who skip grinding get the ground form here at the same 32 Ounce Units as the Don Pablo bag. The title names Colombia but adds no Arabica share and no Kosher label. Medium Roast matches the Eight O’Clock and Amazon Fresh whole bean bags. The bag measures 5.5 x 3.5 x 8.5 inches. Score: roast named 8, bag size and units 9, origin and labels in title 6, dimensions and maker 7.

Who the Amazon Fresh Ground 32 Oz fits best

Choose it if you want ground coffee at 32 Ounce Units with Medium Roast in the title.

Who should skip the Amazon Fresh Ground 32 Oz

Skip it if you want whole bean coffee, because this bag is ground.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

4. Amazon Fresh Colombia Whole Bean Coffee, Medium Roast, 12 Ounce (Pack of 3)

Best 3 Pack Pick 7.3/10Amazon Fresh Colombia Whole Bean Coffee, Medium Roast, 12 Ounce (Pack of 3)
Pros
  • Three bags in one pack
  • Whole bean form
  • 36 Ounce Units
  • Medium Roast named
Cons
  • Each bag reads 12 Ounce
  • Kosher label is not named
  • Maker reads AFS Brands LLC
Dimensions 9 x 3.75 x 7.75 inches
Weight 2.25 pounds
Manufacturer AFS Brands LLC
Units 36 Ounce
This entry is the Pack of 3 version of the Amazon Fresh 12 Ounce whole bean bag. The title keeps Medium Roast and Whole Bean Coffee, and Units read 36 Ounce for the pack. The pack dimensions read 9 x 3.75 x 7.75 inches, wider than the single bag, and the weight reads 2.25 pounds. AFS Brands LLC is the manufacturer, the same maker line as the single bag. The coffee itself matches the single bag on roast and form: Medium Roast whole bean with Colombia in the title. What changes is the pack count and the total Units, 36 Ounce against 12 Ounce. Dimensions and weight grow with the pack, at 9 x 3.75 x 7.75 inches and 2.25 pounds. Score: roast named 8, bag size and units 8, origin and labels in title 6, dimensions and maker 7.

Who the Amazon Fresh 12 Ounce 3 Pack fits best

Choose it if you want three 12 Ounce whole bean bags in one pack at 36 Ounce Units.

Who should skip the Amazon Fresh 12 Ounce 3 Pack

Skip it if one 12 Ounce bag is enough, because this entry is a Pack of 3.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

5. Amazon Fresh Colombia Whole Bean Coffee, Medium Roast, 12 Ounce

Best Single 12 Ounce Pick 6.6/10Amazon Fresh Colombia Whole Bean Coffee, Medium Roast, 12 Ounce
Pros
  • Whole bean form
  • Medium Roast named
  • Colombia named in title
  • Single bag pack
Cons
  • Bag stops at 12 Ounce
  • No pack option in title
  • No Arabica share is named
Dimensions 3.5 x 2.5 x 7 inches
Weight 12 ounces
Manufacturer AFS Brands LLC
Units 12 Ounce
The single Amazon Fresh bag is the smallest entry here at 12 Ounce Units. Its title reads Colombia Whole Bean Coffee with Medium Roast. Dimensions read 3.5 x 2.5 x 7 inches and the weight reads 12 ounces. AFS Brands LLC is the manufacturer, the same maker line as the Pack of 3. The title adds no Arabica share, no Kosher label and no acidity wording. Shoppers comparing the two Amazon Fresh whole bean entries get the same roast and title wording here, in one bag instead of three. The 12 Ounce Units sit below every other bag in the group. Its dimensions of 3.5 x 2.5 x 7 inches are the narrowest set in the group. Score: roast named 8, bag size and units 5, origin and labels in title 6, dimensions and maker 7.

Who the Amazon Fresh 12 Ounce Single fits best

Choose it if you want one 12 Ounce whole bean bag with Medium Roast in the title.

Who should skip the Amazon Fresh 12 Ounce Single

Skip it if you want a larger bag, because this one stops at 12 Ounce Units.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

How to Choose Colombian Coffee Beans

Roast wording

Don Pablo reads Medium Dark Roast while the other four bags read Medium Roast.

Bag size and Units

Units run from 12 Ounce on the single Amazon Fresh bag to 36 Ounce on its Pack of 3. Don Pablo and the Amazon Fresh Ground bag both read 32 Ounce Units.

Whole bean or ground

Four bags read Whole Bean Coffee in the title and the Amazon Fresh 32 Oz bag reads Ground Coffee.

Labels in the title

Eight O’Clock adds 100% Arabica and Kosher Certified, and Don Pablo adds Low Acidity and Supremo. The Amazon Fresh titles carry Colombia and the roast only.

Maker and dimensions

Two Amazon Fresh bags share AFS Brands LLC, the ground bag reads Amazon Fulfillment Services, and Eight O’Clock reads Eight O Clock Coffee Company. Dimensions run from 3.5 x 2.5 x 7 inches to 9.5 x 5 x 3.5 inches.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best Colombian coffee beans?The 2LB Don Pablo Colombian Supremo, Medium Dark Roast, Whole Bean Coffee, Low Acidity, 2 Pound (2 lb) Bag is the pick for most shoppers, with Medium Dark Roast wording and 32 Ounce Units.
Which bags are whole bean?Four bags are whole bean: Don Pablo Supremo, Eight O’Clock Colombian Peaks, the Amazon Fresh 12 Ounce single bag and its Pack of 3.
Which bag is ground coffee?The Amazon Fresh, Colombia Ground Coffee, Medium Roast, 32 Oz bag is the ground entry in this group.
Which bag reads Kosher Certified?The Eight O’Clock Colombian Peaks bag carries Kosher Certified in its title.
What sizes do the bags come in?Units read 12 Ounce, 18 Ounce, 32 Ounce and 36 Ounce across the five bags.

Final Verdict

For most shoppers, the best Colombian coffee beans pick is the 2LB Don Pablo Colombian Supremo, Medium Dark Roast, Whole Bean Coffee, Low Acidity, 2 Pound (2 lb) Bag, with Medium Dark Roast wording and 32 Ounce Units. If you want Kosher Certified and 100% Arabica wording instead, the Eight O’Clock bag carries both labels at 18 Ounce Units. Check the current price and size on Amazon before you order.
Looking for something else? See our other coffee guides, including the espresso machine guide for beginners, the burr coffee grinder guide, the drip coffee maker guide and coffee accessories.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.