As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We research products independently, and commissions never change our picks.

Choosing the best coffee creamer begins with the form and the flavor name in each title. This group holds one 24 fl oz liquid bottle, one 360 pack of singles, one 2 pack of 50.7 oz pumps, one 35.3 oz powder container and one box of 24 singles. Two Coffee mate entries share the brand, and the flavors named are Sweet Cream, Original, French Vanilla and Sweet and Creamy.

Every detail here comes from the Amazon product page and manufacturer information for each entry, and nothing was checked with real equipment in a home kitchen. Our editorial policy page explains how picks and scores are put together.

Best Coffee Creamer: Quick Picks

Best 360 Singles PickNestle Coffee mate Original Non Dairy Creamer Singles, 0.375 oz, 360 Pack

Nestle Coffee mate Original Non Dairy Creamer Singles, 0.375 oz, 360 Pack

  • 360 Pack of singles
  • Original flavor name
  • 0.375 oz per single
Check Price on Amazon
Best French Vanilla Pump PickNestle Coffee mate French Vanilla Non Dairy Creamer Pump, 50.7 oz, 2 Pack

Nestle Coffee mate French Vanilla Non Dairy Creamer Pump, 50.7 oz, 2 Pack

  • French Vanilla named
  • Pump form in title
  • 2 Pack of 50.7 oz
Check Price on Amazon
Best Original Powder PickCoffee Mate Original Powder Creamer, 35.3 Oz

Coffee Mate Original Powder Creamer, 35.3 Oz

  • Powder form in title
  • Original flavor name
  • 35.3 Oz container
Check Price on Amazon

How We Score

We score each pick out of 10 on four criteria, using only what its Amazon product page states. A clearly stated, strong feature earns 8 to 10, a partial one 6 to 7, a feature the page does not mention 5, and one the page shows as absent or contrary 2 to 4. The overall score is the weighted total.

CriterionWeightWhat we look at
Flavor Named30%The flavor name in the title
Size and Units25%The size and the Units figure
Form Named25%Liquid, singles or powder form in the title
Dimensions and Maker20%Package dimensions and the manufacturer line

Compare the 5 Coffee Creamer Entries

ProductBest ForTypeKey SpecScore
Nestle Coffee mate Original Non Dairy Creamer Singles, 0.375 oz, 360 Pack Coffee mate SinglesBest 360 Singles PickCreamer SinglesOriginal; Non-Dairy; Singles; Units 135 Fluid Ounces8.5View
Nestle Coffee mate French Vanilla Non Dairy Creamer Pump, 50.7 oz, 2 Pack Coffee mate PumpBest French Vanilla Pump PickCreamer PumpFrench Vanilla; Non-Dairy; Pump; Units 101.4 Fluid Ounces8.4View
Coffee Mate Original Powder Creamer, 35.3 Oz Coffee Mate PowderBest Original Powder PickPowder CreamerOriginal; Powder; Units 35.3 Ounce7.5View
Chobani Coffee Creamer Sweet Cream 24 fl oz Chobani Sweet CreamBest Sweet Cream Bottle PickLiquid CreamerSweet Cream; Liquid Bottle; Units 24 Fluid Ounces7.3View
International Delight Sweet and Creamy Coffee Creamers, 0.44 fl oz, 24 Count International Delight SinglesBest Sweet and Creamy Singles PickCreamer SinglesSweet and Creamy; Singles; Units 10.55 Fluid Ounces7.1View

1. Nestle Coffee mate Original Non Dairy Creamer Singles, 0.375 oz, 360 Pack

Best 360 Singles Pick 8.5/10Nestle Coffee mate Original Non Dairy Creamer Singles, 0.375 oz, 360 Pack
Pros
  • 360 singles in pack
  • Singles form named
  • Original named in title
  • 135 Fluid Ounces total
Cons
  • No French Vanilla here
  • Maker line reads Nestle
  • Single flavor in the pack
Product Dimensions11.7 x 7.95 x 9.35 inches
Weight8.82 pounds
ManufacturerNestle
Units135 Fluid Ounces

Coffee mate Singles carry the largest pack in this group: Original Non Dairy Creamer Singles at 0.375 oz each, in a 360 Pack. Product dimensions read 11.7 x 7.95 x 9.35 inches and the weight reads 8.82 pounds, the heaviest entry here. The manufacturer line reads Nestle. Units read 135 Fluid Ounces for the full pack.

Singles form matches the International Delight box, at a far larger count. Original also appears on the Coffee Mate powder container title. The 135 Fluid Ounces are the largest Units figure in the group. The pack measures 11.7 x 7.95 x 9.35 inches, the largest set here. Score: flavor named 7, size and units 10, form named 9, dimensions and maker 8.

Who the Coffee mate Singles fits best

Choose it if you want Original singles in a 360 Pack at 135 Fluid Ounces total.

Who should skip the Coffee mate Singles

Skip it if you want a pump or powder form, because this entry is singles.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

2. Nestle Coffee mate French Vanilla Non Dairy Creamer Pump, 50.7 oz, 2 Pack

Best French Vanilla Pump Pick 8.4/10Nestle Coffee mate French Vanilla Non Dairy Creamer Pump, 50.7 oz, 2 Pack
Pros
  • French Vanilla named
  • Pump form in title
  • 101.4 Fluid Ounces total
  • Two pumps in pack
Cons
  • Maker reads Coffee-mate
  • No singles in this pack
  • Single flavor in the pack
Product Dimensions9.2 x 4.7 x 10.5 inches
Weight8.12 pounds
ManufacturerCoffee-mate
Units101.4 Fluid Ounces

Coffee mate Pump is the one pump entry here: French Vanilla Non Dairy Creamer Pump at 50.7 oz, in a 2 Pack. Product dimensions read 9.2 x 4.7 x 10.5 inches, the tallest set in the group, and the weight reads 8.12 pounds. The manufacturer line reads Coffee-mate, a different maker form from the Nestle line on the singles pack.

French Vanilla is a flavor name no other title here carries. The 101.4 Fluid Ounces sit between the 135 Fluid Ounces singles pack and the 35.3 Ounce powder container. Pump form stands alone in this group. The pack measures 9.2 x 4.7 x 10.5 inches. Score: flavor named 9, size and units 9, form named 8, dimensions and maker 7.

Who the Coffee mate Pump fits best

Choose it if you want French Vanilla in a 2 Pack of 50.7 oz pumps.

Who should skip the Coffee mate Pump

Skip it if you want singles, because this entry is a pump pack.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

3. Coffee Mate Original Powder Creamer, 35.3 Oz

Best Original Powder Pick 7.5/10Coffee Mate Original Powder Creamer, 35.3 Oz
Pros
  • Powder form in title
  • Original named in title
  • 35.3 Ounce Units
  • Nestle USA maker
Cons
  • No Non-Dairy wording
  • No singles in this entry
  • Single container in data
Product Dimensions5.6 x 5.6 x 6.4 inches
Weight2.2 pounds
ManufacturerNestle USA
Units35.3 Ounce

Coffee Mate Powder is the one powder entry in this group: Original Powder Creamer at 35.3 Oz. Product dimensions read 5.6 x 5.6 x 6.4 inches and the weight reads 2.2 pounds. The manufacturer line reads Nestle USA, a third maker form in a group with Nestle and Coffee-mate lines. Units read 35.3 Ounce, in ounces rather than fluid ounces.

Original matches the Coffee mate singles pack on flavor name. Powder form stands alone here, against liquid, pump and singles entries. The 35.3 Ounce Units sit between the 101.4 Fluid Ounces pump pack and the 24 Fluid Ounces Chobani bottle. The container measures 5.6 x 5.6 x 6.4 inches. Score: flavor named 7, size and units 7, form named 8, dimensions and maker 8.

Who the Coffee Mate Powder fits best

Choose it if you want Original powder creamer at 35.3 Ounce Units.

Who should skip the Coffee Mate Powder

Skip it if you want a liquid form, because this entry is powder.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

4. Chobani Coffee Creamer Sweet Cream 24 fl oz

Best Sweet Cream Bottle Pick 7.3/10Chobani Coffee Creamer Sweet Cream 24 fl oz
Pros
  • Sweet Cream named
  • Liquid bottle form
  • 24 Fluid Ounces
  • Chobani Inc. maker
Cons
  • Single bottle in the data
  • No Non-Dairy wording
  • No pack count named
Product Dimensions3.07 x 3.03 x 7.91 inches
Weight1.5 pounds
ManufacturerChobani Inc.
Units24 Fluid Ounces

Chobani is the liquid bottle entry here: Coffee Creamer Sweet Cream at 24 fl oz. Product dimensions read 3.07 x 3.03 x 7.91 inches, the narrowest set in the group, and the weight reads 1.5 pounds. The manufacturer line reads Chobani Inc. Units read 24 Fluid Ounces, the second smallest total in the group.

Sweet Cream is a flavor name no other title carries; the other names read Original, French Vanilla and Sweet and Creamy. Liquid bottle form stands alone here. The 24 Fluid Ounces sit above the 10.55 Fluid Ounces International Delight box. The bottle measures 3.07 x 3.03 x 7.91 inches. Score: flavor named 8, size and units 6, form named 7, dimensions and maker 8.

Who the Chobani Sweet Cream fits best

Choose it if you want Sweet Cream in one 24 fl oz liquid bottle.

Who should skip the Chobani Sweet Cream

Skip it if you want singles or a pack, because this entry is a single bottle.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

5. International Delight Sweet and Creamy Coffee Creamers, 0.44 fl oz, 24 Count

Best Sweet and Creamy Singles Pick 7.1/10International Delight Sweet and Creamy Coffee Creamers, 0.44 fl oz, 24 Count
Pros
  • Singles form in title
  • Sweet and Creamy named
  • 24 singles in box
  • WhiteWave maker line
Cons
  • Total reads 10.55 Fluid Ounces
  • Maker reads WhiteWave Foods
  • No Non-Dairy wording
Product Dimensions12.25 x 9 x 5.37 inches
Weight13.92 ounces
ManufacturerWhiteWave Foods Company
Units10.55 Fluid Ounces

International Delight is the small singles box here: Sweet and Creamy Coffee Creamers at 0.44 fl oz each, 24 Count. Product dimensions read 12.25 x 9 x 5.37 inches, the widest set in the group, and the weight reads 13.92 ounces. The manufacturer line reads WhiteWave Foods Company. Units read 10.55 Fluid Ounces, the smallest total here.

Singles form matches the Coffee mate 360 Pack, at a far smaller count and total. Sweet and Creamy is a flavor name no other title carries. The 0.44 fl oz per single figure sits above the 0.375 oz Coffee mate single. The box measures 12.25 x 9 x 5.37 inches. Score: flavor named 8, size and units 4, form named 9, dimensions and maker 7.

Who the International Delight Singles fits best

Choose it if you want Sweet and Creamy singles in a 24 Count box.

Who should skip the International Delight Singles

Skip it if you want a large total volume, because this box reads 10.55 Fluid Ounces.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

How to Choose Coffee Creamer

Form first

The five forms here are singles, a pump pack, powder, a liquid bottle and a small singles box. Two entries are singles, at 360 count and 24 count.

Flavor names

Original appears on two entries, and French Vanilla, Sweet Cream and Sweet and Creamy appear on one each. Match the flavor name in the title to your pick.

Size and Units

Units run from 10.55 Fluid Ounces on the International Delight box to 135 Fluid Ounces on the Coffee mate singles pack. The powder container reads 35.3 Ounce, a weight unit in a fluid group.

Maker lines

Nestle, Coffee-mate and Nestle USA are three maker forms on the Coffee mate brand entries. Chobani Inc. and WhiteWave Foods Company complete the set.

Dimensions

Package dimensions run from 3.07 x 3.03 x 7.91 inches on the Chobani bottle to 12.25 x 9 x 5.37 inches on the International Delight box. The widest box holds the smallest total volume.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best coffee creamer?

The Coffee mate Original Singles 360 Pack is the pick for most shoppers, with Original named in the title at 135 Fluid Ounces total.

Which entries are singles?

Two entries are singles: the Coffee mate 360 Pack and the International Delight 24 Count box.

Which entry is a pump?

The Coffee mate French Vanilla entry is a 2 Pack of 50.7 oz pumps.

Which entry is powder?

The Coffee Mate Original Powder Creamer at 35.3 Oz is the powder entry.

Which flavors are named?

The titles name Sweet Cream, Original, French Vanilla and Sweet and Creamy.

Final Verdict

For most shoppers, the best coffee creamer pick is the Nestle Coffee mate Original Non Dairy Creamer Singles, 0.375 oz, 360 Pack, with Original named in the title at 135 Fluid Ounces total. If you want a pump form instead, the Coffee mate French Vanilla pack holds two 50.7 oz pumps. Check the current price and size on Amazon before you order.

Looking for something else? See our other coffee guides, including the drip coffee maker guide, the coffee maker for office guide, the milk frother guide and coffee accessories.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.