As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We research products independently, and commissions never change our picks.

Choosing the best Italian roast coffee begins with the form, whole bean or ground, and the bag size in each title. Three bags here are whole bean and two are ground, the Starbucks bag and the Lavazza bag. Sizes run from 12 oz to 5 lb, which reads 80 oz in Units. Lavazza reads Extra Dark Roast, and Whole Foods Market reads Organic.

Every detail here comes from the Amazon product page and manufacturer information for each bag, and nothing was checked with real equipment in a home kitchen. Our editorial policy page explains how picks and scores are put together.

Best Italian Roast Coffee: Quick Picks

Best 5 lb Whole Bean PickFresh Roasted Coffee, Italian Roast Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast, Kosher, 5 lb (80 oz)

Fresh Roasted Coffee, Italian Roast Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast, Kosher, 5 lb (80 oz)

  • 5 lb (80 oz) bag
  • Kosher in title
  • Dark Roast named
Check Price on Amazon
Best Italian Dark Roast PickBROOKLYN COFFEE Whole Bean, Italian Dark Roast (2lb)

BROOKLYN COFFEE Whole Bean, Italian Dark Roast (2lb)

  • Italian Dark Roast phrase
  • (2lb) in title
  • Whole bean form
Check Price on Amazon
Best Ground Arabica PickStarbucks Ground Coffee, Dark Roast Coffee, Italian Roast, 100% Arabica, 1 bag (18 oz)

Starbucks Ground Coffee, Dark Roast Coffee, Italian Roast, 100% Arabica, 1 bag (18 oz)

  • Ground form in title
  • 100% Arabica wording
  • 1 bag (18 oz)
Check Price on Amazon

How We Score

We score each pick out of 10 on four criteria, using only what its Amazon product page states. A clearly stated, strong feature earns 8 to 10, a partial one 6 to 7, a feature the page does not mention 5, and one the page shows as absent or contrary 2 to 4. The overall score is the weighted total.

CriterionWeightWhat we look at
Roast Named30%The roast wording named in the title
Size and Units25%The bag size and the Units figure
Whole Bean or Ground in Title25%Whole Bean or Ground wording in the title
Dimensions and Maker20%Package dimensions and the manufacturer line

Compare the 5 Italian Roast Bags

ProductBest ForTypeKey SpecScore
Fresh Roasted Coffee, Italian Roast Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast, Kosher, 5 lb (80 oz) Fresh Roasted ItalianBest 5 lb Whole Bean PickWhole Bean CoffeeItalian Roast; Dark Roast; Whole Bean; Units 80 Ounce8.8View
BROOKLYN COFFEE Whole Bean, Italian Dark Roast (2lb) Brooklyn Italian Dark RoastBest Italian Dark Roast PickWhole Bean CoffeeItalian Dark Roast; Whole Bean; Units 32 Ounce8.3View
Starbucks Ground Coffee, Dark Roast Coffee, Italian Roast, 100% Arabica, 1 bag (18 oz) Starbucks Italian RoastBest Ground Arabica PickGround CoffeeDark Roast; Italian Roast; Ground; Units 18 Ounce8.1View
Lavazza Italian Roast Ground Coffee 12oz Bag, Extra Dark Roast Lavazza Italian RoastBest Extra Dark Ground PickGround CoffeeExtra Dark Roast; Ground; Units 12 Ounce7.4View
Whole Foods Market, Organic Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Italian Roast, 12 Ounce Whole Foods Dark ItalianBest Organic Whole Bean PickWhole Bean CoffeeDark Italian Roast; Organic; Whole Bean; Units 12 Ounce7.3View

1. Fresh Roasted Coffee, Italian Roast Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast, Kosher, 5 lb (80 oz)

Best 5 lb Whole Bean Pick 8.8/10Fresh Roasted Coffee, Italian Roast Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast, Kosher, 5 lb (80 oz)
Pros
  • 80 Ounce Units
  • Whole bean form
  • Dark Roast named
  • Kosher wording in title
Cons
  • No Organic label in title
  • Maker reads Fresh Roasted LLC
  • Single size in its data
Product Dimensions12 x 7.5 x 5 inches
Weight5 pounds
ManufacturerFresh Roasted Coffee LLC
Units80 Ounce

Fresh Roasted Coffee carries the largest bag here: Italian Roast Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast, Kosher, at 5 lb (80 oz). Product dimensions read 12 x 7.5 x 5 inches and the weight reads 5 pounds. The manufacturer line reads Fresh Roasted Coffee LLC. Units read 80 Ounce, far above the 32 Ounce Brooklyn bag below it.

Whole bean form matches the Brooklyn and Whole Foods Market bags, against two ground bags. Dark Roast wording appears in four titles in this group in some form. Kosher appears in this title alone. The bag measures 12 x 7.5 x 5 inches, the largest set here. Score: roast named 9, size and units 10, whole bean or ground in title 8, dimensions and maker 8.

Who the Fresh Roasted Italian fits best

Choose it if you want a 5 lb whole bean bag with Dark Roast and Kosher wording.

Who should skip the Fresh Roasted Italian

Skip it if you want ground coffee, because this bag is whole bean.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

2. BROOKLYN COFFEE Whole Bean, Italian Dark Roast (2lb)

Best Italian Dark Roast Pick 8.3/10BROOKLYN COFFEE Whole Bean, Italian Dark Roast (2lb)
Pros
  • Italian Dark Roast named
  • Whole bean form
  • 32 Ounce Units
  • Short title wording
Cons
  • No Kosher label in title
  • Maker reads OLDE BROOKLYN
  • No Organic label in title
Package Dimensions13.46 x 6.65 x 3.46 inches
Weight2.03 pounds
ManufacturerOLDE BROOKLYN COFFEE
Units32 Ounce

Brooklyn folds the roast into one phrase, Italian Dark Roast, on a Whole Bean bag at (2lb). Package dimensions read 13.46 x 6.65 x 3.46 inches, the longest set in the group, and the weight reads 2.03 pounds. The manufacturer line reads OLDE BROOKLYN COFFEE. Units read 32 Ounce, second in size behind the 5 lb bag.

Italian Dark Roast is a phrase no other title here uses in that order; the others read Italian Roast with a separate Dark word. Whole bean form matches two other bags. The 32 Ounce Units sit above the three smaller bags at 18 and 12 Ounce. The bag measures 13.46 x 6.65 x 3.46 inches. Score: roast named 9, size and units 8, whole bean or ground in title 8, dimensions and maker 8.

Who the Brooklyn Italian Dark Roast fits best

Choose it if you want Italian Dark Roast wording on a 2lb whole bean bag.

Who should skip the Brooklyn Italian Dark Roast

Skip it if you want ground coffee, because this bag is whole bean.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

3. Starbucks Ground Coffee, Dark Roast Coffee, Italian Roast, 100% Arabica, 1 bag (18 oz)

Best Ground Arabica Pick 8.1/10Starbucks Ground Coffee, Dark Roast Coffee, Italian Roast, 100% Arabica, 1 bag (18 oz)
Pros
  • Ground form in title
  • Dark Roast named
  • 100% Arabica wording
  • 18 Ounce Units
Cons
  • Bag stops at 18 oz
  • No Kosher label in title
  • No Organic label in title
Package Dimensions9.54 x 5.16 x 2.7 inches
Weight1.13 pounds
ManufacturerStarbucks Coffee
Units18 Ounce

Starbucks is one of two ground bags here: Ground Coffee, Dark Roast Coffee, Italian Roast, 100% Arabica, 1 bag (18 oz). Package dimensions read 9.54 x 5.16 x 2.7 inches and the weight reads 1.13 pounds. Starbucks Coffee is the manufacturer. Units read 18 Ounce, between the 32 Ounce Brooklyn bag and the 12 Ounce bags.

Ground form matches the Lavazza bag, against three whole bean bags. 100% Arabica appears in this title alone in the group. Dark Roast wording matches the Fresh Roasted and Whole Foods Market titles in some form. The bag measures 9.54 x 5.16 x 2.7 inches. Score: roast named 9, size and units 7, whole bean or ground in title 8, dimensions and maker 8.

Who the Starbucks Italian Roast fits best

Choose it if you want ground Italian Roast with 100% Arabica wording at 18 Ounce Units.

Who should skip the Starbucks Italian Roast

Skip it if you want whole bean coffee, because this bag is ground.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

4. Lavazza Italian Roast Ground Coffee 12oz Bag, Extra Dark Roast

Best Extra Dark Ground Pick 7.4/10Lavazza Italian Roast Ground Coffee 12oz Bag, Extra Dark Roast
Pros
  • Extra Dark Roast named
  • Ground form in title
  • Bag named in title
  • Lavazza maker line
Cons
  • Bag stops at 12oz
  • Maker reads Lavazza Coffee Company
  • No Arabica share in title
Product Dimensions9.21 x 3.54 x 1.81 inches
Weight12 ounces
ManufacturerLavazza Coffee Company
Units12 Ounce

Lavazza carries the strongest roast phrase here: Italian Roast Ground Coffee 12oz Bag, Extra Dark Roast. Product dimensions read 9.21 x 3.54 x 1.81 inches, the thinnest set in the group, and the weight reads 12 ounces. The manufacturer line reads Lavazza Coffee Company. Units read 12 Ounce, tied at the smallest size here.

Extra Dark Roast is wording no other title uses; the others read Dark Roast or Italian Dark Roast. Ground form matches the Starbucks bag. The 12 Ounce Units tie the Whole Foods Market bag at the bottom size in the group. The bag measures 9.21 x 3.54 x 1.81 inches. Score: roast named 9, size and units 5, whole bean or ground in title 8, dimensions and maker 7.

Who the Lavazza Italian Roast fits best

Choose it if you want Extra Dark Roast wording in a 12 Ounce ground bag.

Who should skip the Lavazza Italian Roast

Skip it if you want a larger bag, because this one stops at 12oz.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

5. Whole Foods Market, Organic Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Italian Roast, 12 Ounce

Best Organic Whole Bean Pick 7.3/10Whole Foods Market, Organic Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Italian Roast, 12 Ounce
Pros
  • Organic label in title
  • Whole bean form
  • Dark Italian Roast named
  • Whole Foods maker
Cons
  • Bag stops at 12 Ounce
  • No Kosher label in title
  • Weight reads 12.87 ounces
Product Dimensions3.55 x 3.98 x 6.8 inches
Weight12.87 ounces
ManufacturerWhole Foods Market
Units12 Ounce

Whole Foods Market is the Organic entry here: Organic Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Italian Roast, 12 Ounce. Product dimensions read 3.55 x 3.98 x 6.8 inches and the weight reads 12.87 ounces, a weight figure above the 12 Ounce Units line. Whole Foods Market is the manufacturer. Dark Italian Roast reverses the word order used by Brooklyn.

The 12 Ounce Units tie the Lavazza bag at the smallest size in the group. Organic appears in this title alone. Whole bean form matches the Fresh Roasted and Brooklyn bags. The bag measures 3.55 x 3.98 x 6.8 inches, the smallest set here. Score: roast named 8, size and units 5, whole bean or ground in title 8, dimensions and maker 8.

Who the Whole Foods Dark Italian fits best

Choose it if you want Organic wording on a 12 Ounce whole bean bag.

Who should skip the Whole Foods Dark Italian

Skip it if you want ground coffee, because this bag is whole bean.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

How to Choose Italian Roast Coffee

Form first

Three bags are whole bean and two are ground, the Starbucks and Lavazza bags. The form word sits in every title in this group.

Roast wording

Lavazza reads Extra Dark Roast, Brooklyn reads Italian Dark Roast, and Whole Foods Market reads Dark Italian Roast. Fresh Roasted and Starbucks pair Italian Roast with a separate Dark Roast line.

Bag size and Units

Units run from 12 Ounce on the Lavazza and Whole Foods Market bags to 80 Ounce on the Fresh Roasted bag. Starbucks reads 18 Ounce and Brooklyn reads 32 Ounce.

Labels in the title

Kosher appears on the Fresh Roasted bag, Organic on the Whole Foods Market bag, and 100% Arabica on the Starbucks bag. Each label sits on one title only.

Maker lines

Makers read Fresh Roasted Coffee LLC, OLDE BROOKLYN COFFEE, Starbucks Coffee, Lavazza Coffee Company and Whole Foods Market. Two maker lines run longer than the brand word in the title.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best Italian roast coffee?

The Fresh Roasted Coffee 5 lb bag is the pick for most shoppers, with Dark Roast and Kosher wording at 80 Ounce Units.

Which bags are ground?

Two bags are ground: the Starbucks Italian Roast bag and the Lavazza Extra Dark Roast bag.

Which bags are whole bean?

Three bags are whole bean: Fresh Roasted, Brooklyn and Whole Foods Market.

Which bag reads Extra Dark Roast?

The Lavazza bag reads Extra Dark Roast in its title.

Which bag reads Organic?

The Whole Foods Market bag reads Organic in its title.

Final Verdict

For most shoppers, the best Italian roast coffee pick is the Fresh Roasted Coffee, Italian Roast Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast, Kosher, 5 lb (80 oz), with Dark Roast and Kosher wording at 80 Ounce Units. If you want ground coffee instead, the Starbucks bag pairs Dark Roast with 100% Arabica wording at 18 Ounce Units. Check the current price and size on Amazon before you order.

Looking for something else? See our other coffee guides, including the burr coffee grinder guide, the French press guide, the espresso machine guide and coffee accessories.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.