As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We research products independently, and commissions never change our picks.

Choosing the best Sumatra coffee beans begins with the roast word, the form and the labels in each title. Four bags here are whole bean and one, the Starbucks 18 oz bag, is ground. Four titles read Dark Roast and one, Fresh Roasted Coffee, reads Medium Roast. Three titles read Organic, and bag sizes run from 12 oz to 32 oz. Every detail here comes from the Amazon product page and manufacturer information for each bag, and nothing was checked with real equipment in a home kitchen. Our editorial policy page explains how picks and scores are put together.

Best Sumatra Coffee Beans: Quick Picks

Best Gayo Mountain PickMagnum Exotics Organic Sumatra Gayo Mountain Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast Coffee Beans, Caffeinated, Roasted Bulk Brew, Fresh Roast, 32 oz (2 lb) Bag

Magnum Exotics Organic Sumatra Gayo Mountain Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast Coffee Beans, Caffeinated, Roasted Bulk Brew, Fresh Roast, 32 oz (2 lb) Bag

  • Gayo Mountain in title
  • 32 oz (2 lb) Bag
  • Organic in title
Check Price on Amazon
Best Medium Roast Mandheling PickFresh Roasted Coffee, 100% Sumatra Mandheling Whole Bean Coffee, Medium Roast, Single Origin, Kosher, 2 lb (32 oz)

Fresh Roasted Coffee, 100% Sumatra Mandheling Whole Bean Coffee, Medium Roast, Single Origin, Kosher, 2 lb (32 oz)

  • Medium Roast in title
  • Single Origin wording
  • Kosher in title
Check Price on Amazon
Best USDA Organic Reserve PickSumatra Mandheling Dark Roast Coffee, USDA Organic, Whole Bean, Reserve, Fair Trade, Fresh Roasted 16 ounce

Sumatra Mandheling Dark Roast Coffee, USDA Organic, Whole Bean, Reserve, Fair Trade, Fresh Roasted 16 ounce

  • USDA Organic in title
  • Reserve and Fair Trade wording
  • Mandheling named
Check Price on Amazon

How We Score

We score each pick out of 10 on four criteria, using only what its Amazon product page states. A clearly stated, strong feature earns 8 to 10, a partial one 6 to 7, a feature the page does not mention 5, and one the page shows as absent or contrary 2 to 4. The overall score is the weighted total.
Criterion Weight What we look at
Roast Named 30% The roast level named in the title
Bag Size and Units 25% The bag size and the Units figure
Origin and Labels in Title 25% Origin and label wording in the title
Dimensions and Maker 20% Package dimensions and the manufacturer line

Compare the 5 Sumatra Coffee Bags

Product Best For Type Key Spec Score
Magnum Exotics Organic Sumatra Gayo Mountain Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast Coffee Beans, Caffeinated, Roasted Bulk Brew, Fresh Roast, 32 oz (2 lb) Bag Magnum Gayo Mountain Best Gayo Mountain Pick Whole Bean Coffee Dark Roast; Whole Bean; Organic; Units 32 Ounce 8.3 View
Fresh Roasted Coffee, 100% Sumatra Mandheling Whole Bean Coffee, Medium Roast, Single Origin, Kosher, 2 lb (32 oz) Fresh Roasted Mandheling Best Medium Roast Mandheling Pick Whole Bean Coffee Medium Roast; Whole Bean; Single Origin; Units 32 Ounce 8.2 View
Sumatra Mandheling Dark Roast Coffee, USDA Organic, Whole Bean, Reserve, Fair Trade, Fresh Roasted 16 ounce Volcanica Mandheling Best USDA Organic Reserve Pick Whole Bean Coffee Dark Roast; Whole Bean; USDA Organic; Units 16 Ounce 8.0 View
Amazon Fresh Organic Fair Trade Sumatra Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast, 12 Ounce Amazon Fresh Sumatra Best Fair Trade 12 Ounce Pick Whole Bean Coffee Dark Roast; Whole Bean; Organic Fair Trade; Units 12 Ounce 7.1 View
Starbucks Ground Coffee Sumatra Dark Roast, 18 oz Bag Starbucks Ground Sumatra Best Ground Sumatra Pick Ground Coffee Dark Roast; Ground Coffee; Units 18 Ounce 7.0 View

1. Magnum Exotics Organic Sumatra Gayo Mountain Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast Coffee Beans, Caffeinated, Roasted Bulk Brew, Fresh Roast, 32 oz (2 lb) Bag

Best Gayo Mountain Pick 8.3/10Magnum Exotics Organic Sumatra Gayo Mountain Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast Coffee Beans, Caffeinated, Roasted Bulk Brew, Fresh Roast, 32 oz (2 lb) Bag
Pros
  • Dark Roast named
  • Whole bean form
  • 32 Ounce Units
  • Gayo Mountain named
Cons
  • No Fair Trade wording
  • No Kosher label in title
  • No Single Origin wording
Dimensions 3.54 x 6.3 x 13.39 inches
Weight 2 pounds
Manufacturer Magnum Exotics
Units 32 Ounce
Magnum names the Gayo Mountain origin in its title, a place name no other title in this group carries. The title reads Organic Sumatra Gayo Mountain Whole Bean Coffee and Dark Roast Coffee Beans, with Caffeinated, Roasted Bulk Brew and Fresh Roast wording, at 32 oz (2 lb) Bag. Dimensions read 3.54 x 6.3 x 13.39 inches and the weight reads 2 pounds. The 32 Ounce Units tie the Fresh Roasted bag at the top size in this group. Dark Roast matches three other titles here, and the form is whole bean. The title adds no Fair Trade, Kosher or Single Origin wording. Magnum Exotics is the manufacturer, and the bag measures 3.54 x 6.3 x 13.39 inches. Score: roast named 8, bag size and units 9, origin and labels in title 8, dimensions and maker 8.

Who the Magnum Gayo Mountain fits best

Choose it if you want a Dark Roast Gayo Mountain whole bean bag at 32 Ounce Units.

Who should skip the Magnum Gayo Mountain

Skip it if you want Fair Trade wording, because this title carries none.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

2. Fresh Roasted Coffee, 100% Sumatra Mandheling Whole Bean Coffee, Medium Roast, Single Origin, Kosher, 2 lb (32 oz)

Best Medium Roast Mandheling Pick 8.2/10Fresh Roasted Coffee, 100% Sumatra Mandheling Whole Bean Coffee, Medium Roast, Single Origin, Kosher, 2 lb (32 oz)
Pros
  • Medium Roast named
  • Whole bean form
  • 32 Ounce Units
  • Mandheling named in title
Cons
  • No Organic label in title
  • No Fair Trade wording
  • No Reserve wording in title
Dimensions 9 x 6 x 4 inches
Weight 2 pounds
Manufacturer FRESH ROASTED COFFEE LLC
Units 32 Ounce
Fresh Roasted Coffee is the one Medium Roast title in a group of Dark Roast bags. Its title reads 100% Sumatra Mandheling Whole Bean Coffee with Single Origin and Kosher wording, at 2 lb (32 oz). Dimensions read 9 x 6 x 4 inches and the weight reads 2 pounds. The manufacturer line reads FRESH ROASTED COFFEE LLC, and Units read 32 Ounce. Mandheling appears in two titles here, this one and the Volcanica bag, and this is the Medium Roast one of the pair. The 32 Ounce Units match the Magnum bag at the top of the group. No Organic or Fair Trade label appears in the title. The bag measures 9 x 6 x 4 inches. Score: roast named 7, bag size and units 9, origin and labels in title 9, dimensions and maker 8.

Who the Fresh Roasted Mandheling fits best

Choose it if you want a Medium Roast Mandheling whole bean bag at 32 Ounce Units.

Who should skip the Fresh Roasted Mandheling

Skip it if you want Dark Roast wording, because this title reads Medium Roast.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

3. Sumatra Mandheling Dark Roast Coffee, USDA Organic, Whole Bean, Reserve, Fair Trade, Fresh Roasted 16 ounce

Best USDA Organic Reserve Pick 8.0/10Sumatra Mandheling Dark Roast Coffee, USDA Organic, Whole Bean, Reserve, Fair Trade, Fresh Roasted 16 ounce
Pros
  • Dark Roast named
  • Whole bean form
  • Fair Trade wording
  • Reserve wording in title
Cons
  • Bag stops at 16-ounce
  • No Kosher label in title
  • No Single Origin wording
Dimensions 3 x 2.5 x 9 inches
Weight 1 pounds
Manufacturer Volcanica Coffee
Units 16 Ounce
Volcanica builds the longest label list in this group: Sumatra Mandheling Dark Roast Coffee with USDA Organic, Whole Bean, Reserve, Fair Trade and Fresh Roasted wording, at 16-ounce. Dimensions read 3 x 2.5 x 9 inches and the weight reads 1 pounds. Volcanica Coffee is the manufacturer. Units read 16 Ounce, half the figure of the two 32 Ounce bags. Fair Trade appears in two titles here, this one and the Amazon Fresh bag, and Reserve appears in this title alone. Dark Roast matches the Magnum, Amazon Fresh and Starbucks titles. The bag size sits between the 12 Ounce and 32 Ounce entries. The bag measures 3 x 2.5 x 9 inches. Score: roast named 8, bag size and units 6, origin and labels in title 10, dimensions and maker 8.

Who the Volcanica Mandheling fits best

Choose it if you want USDA Organic, Reserve and Fair Trade wording on a 16 Ounce bag.

Who should skip the Volcanica Mandheling

Skip it if you want a 32 Ounce bag, because this one reads 16 Ounce Units.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

4. Amazon Fresh Organic Fair Trade Sumatra Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast, 12 Ounce

Best Fair Trade 12 Ounce Pick 7.1/10Amazon Fresh Organic Fair Trade Sumatra Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast, 12 Ounce
Pros
  • Dark Roast named
  • Whole bean form
  • Organic label in title
  • Fair Trade wording
Cons
  • Bag stops at 12 Ounce
  • No Mandheling name in title
  • Maker reads AFS Brands LLC
Dimensions 3.5 x 7 x 2.5 inches
Weight 12 ounces
Manufacturer AFS Brands LLC
Units 12 Ounce
Amazon Fresh pairs Organic with Fair Trade in the shortest title of this group: Organic Fair Trade Sumatra Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast, 12 Ounce. Dimensions read 3.5 x 7 x 2.5 inches and the weight reads 12 ounces. AFS Brands LLC is the manufacturer. The title names Sumatra without a Mandheling or Gayo Mountain place name. The 12 Ounce Units are the smallest figure in the group, below the 16 Ounce Volcanica bag. Dark Roast matches three other titles, and the form is whole bean. No Kosher, Reserve or Single Origin wording appears in the title. The bag measures 3.5 x 7 x 2.5 inches. Score: roast named 8, bag size and units 5, origin and labels in title 8, dimensions and maker 7.

Who the Amazon Fresh Sumatra fits best

Choose it if you want Organic Fair Trade wording on a 12 Ounce Dark Roast bag.

Who should skip the Amazon Fresh Sumatra

Skip it if you want a place name like Mandheling, because this title names Sumatra only.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

5. Starbucks Ground Coffee Sumatra Dark Roast, 18 oz Bag

Best Ground Sumatra Pick 7.0/10Starbucks Ground Coffee Sumatra Dark Roast, 18 oz Bag
Pros
  • Ground form in title
  • Dark Roast named
  • 18 Ounce Units
  • Sumatra named in title
Cons
  • No whole bean form offered
  • No Organic label in title
  • No Fair Trade wording
Package Dimensions 9.49 x 5.01 x 2.8 inches
Weight 1.13 pounds
Manufacturer Starbucks Coffee
Units 18 Ounce
Starbucks is the ground entry in this group; the other four bags are whole bean. The title reads Ground Coffee Sumatra Dark Roast at 18 oz Bag, with no Organic, Fair Trade or Kosher wording. Package dimensions read 9.49 x 5.01 x 2.8 inches and the weight reads 1.13 pounds. Starbucks Coffee is the manufacturer and Units read 18 Ounce. Buyers who skip grinding get the ground form here, at 18 Ounce Units between the 16 Ounce and 32 Ounce bags. Dark Roast matches the Magnum, Volcanica and Amazon Fresh titles. The title names Sumatra with no Mandheling or Gayo Mountain wording. The bag measures 9.49 x 5.01 x 2.8 inches. Score: roast named 8, bag size and units 7, origin and labels in title 5, dimensions and maker 8.

Who the Starbucks Ground Sumatra fits best

Choose it if you want ground Sumatra coffee at 18 Ounce Units with Dark Roast in the title.

Who should skip the Starbucks Ground Sumatra

Skip it if you want whole bean coffee, because this bag is ground.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

How to Choose Sumatra Coffee Beans

Roast wording

Four titles read Dark Roast and the Fresh Roasted Coffee title reads Medium Roast.

Whole bean or ground

Four bags read Whole Bean in the title and the Starbucks bag reads Ground Coffee.

Labels in the title

Three titles read Organic, two read Fair Trade, and one reads Kosher. Volcanica carries USDA Organic, Reserve and Fair Trade in one title.

Place names

Magnum names Gayo Mountain, and Fresh Roasted Coffee and Volcanica name Mandheling. Amazon Fresh and Starbucks name Sumatra with no place name added.

Bag size and Units

Units run from 12 Ounce on the Amazon Fresh bag to 32 Ounce on the Magnum and Fresh Roasted Coffee bags. Starbucks reads 18 Ounce and Volcanica reads 16 Ounce.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best Sumatra coffee beans?The Magnum Exotics Gayo Mountain bag is the pick for most shoppers, with Dark Roast wording, whole bean form and 32 Ounce Units.
Which bags are whole bean?Four bags are whole bean: Magnum Gayo Mountain, Fresh Roasted Mandheling, Volcanica Mandheling and Amazon Fresh Sumatra.
Which bag is ground coffee?The Starbucks Ground Coffee Sumatra Dark Roast, 18 oz Bag is the ground entry in this group.
Which titles read Organic?Three titles read Organic: Magnum Exotics, Volcanica Mandheling and Amazon Fresh Sumatra.
Which bag is Medium Roast?The Fresh Roasted Coffee bag is the Medium Roast entry; the other four titles read Dark Roast.

Final Verdict

For most shoppers, the best Sumatra coffee beans pick is the Magnum Exotics Organic Sumatra Gayo Mountain Whole Bean Coffee, Dark Roast Coffee Beans, Caffeinated, Roasted Bulk Brew, Fresh Roast, 32 oz (2 lb) Bag, with Dark Roast wording and 32 Ounce Units. If you want Medium Roast instead, the Fresh Roasted bag pairs that roast word with Single Origin and Kosher wording at the same 32 Ounce Units. Check the current price and size on Amazon before you order.
Looking for something else? See our other coffee guides, including the burr coffee grinder guide, the French press guide, the drip coffee maker guide and coffee accessories.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.